The Bengalis: A Portrait Of A Community

The Bengalis, A portrait of a community is a part history, part memoir and part travelogue of an ethnicity who’ve produced not only Nobel laureates but also several revolutionaries of the highest stature. 

 

The Bengalis, A portrait of a community book by Sudeep Chakravarti

The Bengalis, A Portrait of a community

In India, we’ve the four fold caste system or the Varna vyavastha. But, in Bengal and amongst the Bengalis there is another division within the society. It’s divided into Bhadralok and Chotolok. 

The former can be defined as the people who are educated, well cultured and speak the Angrezi ( English) other than Bangla in a fluent way. 

The latter can be defined as the people who are from the lowest rung of the society. They are not well educated and they usually do menial jobs. 

Although, the author of this book has tried to explain about the community from which he belongs. But, somehow he used words and language which is hard to grasp. He could’ve conveyed the story in a simpler way for Bengalis and Non – Bengalis readers alike. 

Being a Bengali and from the Bhadralok community. The book has been written for the elites by an elite. 

That’s why it is said that writing in a tough language is too easy but conveying the message in a layman’s words is too tough. 

So, let’s return to the topic of our discussion, The Bengalis. 

Bengal and Bengalis have always shown the way in both good or bad way to India, isn’t it. 

Be it the fight against the evils of the society like child marriage, Sati pratha, education and remarrying of widows to the communal mayhem of 1946 in which they’ve participated and which eventually led to the partition of India in 1947.

The Bengal and Bengalis are an epitome of the word, Paradox. From extreme left to the extreme right, people of every shade can be found in the streets of Kolkata, Dhaka and other cities of Bengal. That’s what made them a unique community. 

So, let’s explore about Bengal and the Bengalis who’ve experienced the partition of their land twice. 

 

Who are the Bengalis? 

Bengalis are the third largest ethno-linguistic group in the world, after the Han Chinese and the Arabs. 

This community have produced Nobel laureates, Scientists, Social reformers, freedom fighters, historians, Miss Universe and even revolutionaries of unparalleled courage. 

Till date, Bengalis have produced four Nobel laureates , Rabindranath Tagore, Amartya Sen, Muhammad Yunus and Abhijit Banerjee. 

In fact, Rabindranath Tagore was the first Asian and Bengali who has won the Nobel Prize for literature in 1913.

The Bengalis in India have a province, West Bengal, The Bengalis in Bangladesh have a country. 

But, this community also suffered a lot. Be it the Great Famine of 1943 to the Great Calcutta Killings of 1946. Bengalis as a whole have had experienced both death and starvation. 

Although, India was partitioned once in 1947, but Bengal was partitioned twice. First in 1905 and then in 1971, When an independent nation by the name of Bangladesh was born. 

 

Bengal and Bengalis Divided:

British ruled over India for almost 150 years. They were able to rule because they’ve mastered the craft of Divide and Rule. 

The British realises as early as 1857 during the Sepoy mutiny or the First war of Independence. That to rule a country as diverse as India they need to widen the religious fault lines. And they did that job with full zeal. 

This cunning policy was utilised in 1905 when British decided to divide the province of Bengal along the religious lines. 

Lord Curzon, the man behind the Partition of Bengal. He divided Bengal into West Bengal for the Hindus and East Bengal for the Muslims. 

In fact, the seed of India’s partition was sowed in 1905 when Bengal was divided.

 

Old street of Kolkata with the famous yellow taxi of Kolkata

Kolkata, The City Of Joy

 The cocktail of religious sectarianism and fundamentalism with which the Bengalis were intoxicated showed its true colors when they butchered themselves in 1946, during the Direct Action Day. 

Although, in 1911, the decision to partition Bengal was annulled but the hearts were already divided. 

In fact, in 1911, the capital of British India which was till then Calcutta was transferred to New Delhi. And it hurt the pride of Bengal and Bengalis, especially the Bhadralok community of Calcutta (Now Kolkata) for whom the world revolves around their city. 

In fact, even now you will find people in the streets of Kolkata who will tell you that how a city which was once termed as the culture capital of British India became a backwater. 

The grudge against Lutyens Delhi can be gauged in the labyrinths of Kolkata. 

 

The Birth of Bangladesh:

To understand the birth of Bangladesh we need to go back to the year 1947 when Pakistan was formed. 

In August 1947, Pakistan was created. It was formed on the basis of two nation theory. 

According to this theory, Hindus and Muslims are two different entities and they can’t live together. 

Although, Pakistan was formed but it was a nation which was divided into two wings, West Pakistan and East Pakistan. And in between these two wings was India. 

Thousands of Kilometers separated the one wing from the another. It was an example of the bad political cartography. 

The only thing which binded these two wings of Pakistan is the religion which they followed. It was Islam.

But religion can’t be a unifying factor when it comes to the formation of a nation. This hypothesis proved right when the people of East Pakistan (Now Bangladesh) fought a brutal war in 1971 against West Pakistan (Now Pakistan) for their identity, culture, language and most importantly for their dignity and freedom. 

Millions of Bengalis gave up their lives for an independent Bangladesh, literally, The country of Bengalis. 

This was the second time when the land of Bengal was divided. 

When Bangladesh gained their hard won freedom in 1971, they choose the song written by Rabindranath Tagore, Amar Sonar Bangla ( My Golden Bengal) as their national anthem. 

In fact, Rabindranath Tagore was the only person in this world who gave national anthem to two nations, India and Bangladesh. An unbreakable feat in itself. 

 

The cradle of Revolutionaries:

In India, the names of Revolutionaries like Bhagat Singh, Chandrashekhar Azad are renowned for their bravery with which they fought against the British and gave up their lives to free India. 

But, before them, the revolutionaries of Bengal were already gave the British a bloody nose. 

The names of Rash Behari Bose, Prafulla Chaki, Benoy, Badal and Dinesh, Aurobindo Ghosh and many more like them are revered in West Bengal for their bravado. 

In fact, the most audacious attack on the British Raj was done by the forgotten revolutionaries of Bengal. The The Chittagong armoury raid under the leadership of Master Surya Sen. 

Bengalis have portrayed as the meek people but they are not. The land which gave birth to people like these revolutionaries and the legendary Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose can’t be termed as weak. 

Although, Prejudices die hard. Either, a person read about the land and its history, or they travel length and breadth of that nation. Only then one can get rid off such kind of preconceived notions, isn’t it. 

 

A Shared history:

Other than West Bengal and Bangladesh, the Bengalis are also a formidable community in the Indian States like Tripura and Assam. 

Together they form a Banglasphere. Be it the festival of Durga Puja, Saraswati Puja, Eid and other important festivities. The Bengalis enjoy the traditions which their forefathers started ages ago. 

Bengalis celebrating the festival of Durga Puja

Durga Puja, The festival which unites Bengal and Bengalis.

A Bengali Hindu and a Bengali Muslim not only share the same language but they also share the same culture and traditions which they are part of. 

Even in Bangladesh where the state religion is Islam, you will see womenfolk sporting bindi and Sari. A non-Bengali can hardly differentiate between a Bengali of West Bengal and a Bengali of Bangladesh. 

Because it’s the culture and traditions which binds a community together rather than a religion. 

 

Look East-

India shares its longest international border with Bangladesh. It’s a porous border. The issue of illegal migrants in India which is not only a burning issue but it’s a cause for several riots which several Indian States had experienced. 

Although, if you look at the map of India you’ll see that it’s the state of West Bengal which connects the Northeastern States of India with the mainland. 

But, several northeast states of India like Tripura, Assam and Meghalaya also shares border with Bangladesh. 

If India wanna utilise its full potential then it needs to shed an attitude which promotes myopic viewpoint. 

Bangladesh can help India in connecting these states with the mainland in a hassle free manner. It will not only reduce the travel time but it will also connect people to people. 

Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, The world is one family. This is what Indian ancient scriptures said. And if we Indians strongly believe in these lines then we need to follow that sentence not only in letter but also in spirit. 

West Bengal and Northeast India is India’s gateway to the Southeast Asian nations. And this route will flourish only if we able to maintain good and friendly relations with Bangladesh. 

Cross cultural movement of people should be encouraged. The issue of migrants can be handled in a humane way.

 Let the people of West Bengal and Northeast India to have their lunch and dinner in Dhaka, Chittagong and other cities of Bangladesh, and vice versa.

 Only then we will be able to say that India is a vishwaguru (World Leader) in a true sense. 

I’ll conclude with these lines of Dr APJ Abdul Kalam:

“Dream, dream, dream. Dreams transform into thoughts and thoughts result in action.”

I hope you like this, Thanks for reading, Jai Hind. 

My Ratings: ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5) 

 

Order your copy from here-

Digiprove sealCopyright secured by Digiprove © 2021 Yash Sharma

Yash Sharma

Namaste reader, My name is Yash, and books for me are like a medicine, which removes my ignorance and also helps me in behaving more like a human.Though I live in the world’s largest democracy, India, but when I look around, I realized that this democratic nation of mine has turned into a kind of feudal oligarchy or kleptocracy, where people from a particular community or I would say particular surname has hijacked this democracy, and the political parties in India has turned itself into a kind of family enterprises where the family members are the only shareholders. And I want to change this, and books are a weapon which is helping me, so that I can help others and my nation.Shukriya for reading this Thought of mine.

You may also like...

14 Responses

  1. Aishwarya says:

    Much awaited one and I must say the wait was worth it. No wonder Bengal has produced many gems and will continue to do so if only it is not overshadowed by POLITICS…
    Kudos to you👍👍👍👍
    You have put in a lot of efforts in reading the book and then writing this one.

    • You’ve rightly said that the land of Bengal has produced many gems. I’m sure in the near future it will give birth to many more gems who will do good for the humanity. And thanks for your kind words. Glad that you enjoyed reading it.

  2. Ritika Jain says:

    “Writing in a tough language is too easy but conveying the message in a layman’s words is too tough.”And you have done your job incredibly well..!!.It might be a tough book but you have brought out its essence so well..Easy to understand and beautifully presented.
    The borders may separate but the culture keeps connected.
    Bengal holds a very special place be it in our history, culture,literature,music,polity,geography,ecology and even food . Land that has gifted this country with great personalities in almost all the fields.
    U have written it all and written so well.
    Keep doing the good work.
    Thanks for the article 👏👏

    • Shukriya, Ritika for this kind feedback. I’m glad that you have enjoyed it thoroughly. The land of Bengal has produced great people and it will give birth to many more in the near future too.

  3. Sinthiya Oishi says:

    As a Bengali girl I really like this article. You said truly that for foreigners to identify Indian Bengali and Bangladeshi Bengali is difficult. Sometimes my foreigners friends become confuse when I say India and Bangladesh aren’t same country…….
    Indian Bengali people are called “Ghoti” and Bangladeshi Bengali people are called “Bangal”😅😅😅
    Thanks again for this beautiful article………

  4. Akash says:

    This is the article covering all the aspects of Bengalis, the desire of connecting W.Bengal with North Eastern states via Bangladesh may be very practicable & might be possible.

  5. Tyra says:

    It’s good to know that Hindus and Muslims showed unity in aspects of culture and traditions. And set aside their religion.

    All in all you did a great job again Yash. Skills again tested to explain what this book is trying to imply to us readers…:)

  6. Akshat says:

    Nice one, informative and interesting.

  7. Prabal Singh Nain says:

    Well written brother… another great article….. Bengal has its own great history in many aspects….at the time of Bengal partition when Bangladesh was formed there were many riots on that time just like when pakistan is formed….But now present scenario is that Bangladesh is more trust worthy than pakistan…. we can expect any help from Bangladesh but not from pakistan….on India and Pakistan borders we listen on news that there is firing for few days in every month….I know I got distracted from the topic…..I am sure that you also know a myth about bengal that they know Blackmagic….Did you believe in this…… Recently bengal election has over…. According to you who will be the best leader for bengal after Didiji……I got suprised when I get to know that kolkata have the maximum number of railway platform that is 23….and that yellow taxi..and the first underground metro…and the famous Howrah bridge…I want to see the bridge if I got a chance…and the durga puja festival…if you got a chance would you like to explore bengal..??

    • Thanks for your kind words. I’m glad that you enjoyed the article.

      As you’ve asked about Black magic. I don’t know anything about it so I can’t comment.

      In politics things can change quickly. So, I can’t predict about it. At present, Didi is there, maybe in the near future we’ll see other people also.

      And I’ve already explored the city of Kolkata. And in the near future I will travel to other cities of Bengal also.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *